does andy’s frozen custard have milkshakes? What to order

Yes, Andy’s Frozen Custard serves shakes made with its frozen custard. They are thicker and richer than many ordinary milkshakes, so they can be a filling treat rather than a light drink.

Menu names, flavors, and availability can vary by location. Here’s what to expect from a custard shake, how it compares with other Andy’s treats, and what to ask before ordering if you have a dietary restriction or want a particular flavor.

Does andy’s frozen custard have milkshakes?

Yes. Andy’s Frozen Custard offers shakes made with frozen custard. You may see them called shakes on the menu, even though customers often use “milkshake” to describe the same kind of drink.

A custard shake is generally richer and thicker than a shake made with standard ice cream. Frozen custard contains egg yolk as well as milk and cream, which gives it a dense, smooth texture. Blending it with milk and flavoring makes a drinkable dessert, but the consistency can still be quite thick.

That distinction matters if you expect a thin, easy-to-sip drink. A custard-based shake may take more effort to drink through a straw, especially when it is freshly made. If you prefer a thinner texture, ask whether the location can make it less thick or recommend an option that better fits your preference.

Andy’s is known for frozen custard, so its shakes are a way to enjoy that base in a blended form. The exact menu wording and available choices can differ from store to store. Check the menu for your local shop or ask the staff before ordering a specific flavor.

What makes an Andy’s custard shake different?

The biggest difference is the base. A traditional milkshake is commonly made by blending ice cream with milk. A custard shake uses frozen custard, which contains egg yolk and has a dense, creamy texture. The added richness can make the drink taste more like a spoonable dessert than a thin beverage.

Frozen custard is also served very cold. That helps it hold a thick consistency, although a blended shake will soften as it sits. For the best texture, drink it soon after it is served rather than leaving it in a warm car or setting it aside for a long time.

Keep in mind that “thicker” is a general expectation, not a guarantee of one exact consistency. Preparation, chosen flavor, serving conditions, and the time between blending and drinking can all affect the result. If texture matters to you, ask the shop what to expect before placing your order.

Custard, shake, and milkshake: are they the same thing?

Not exactly. Frozen custard is the frozen dessert used as a base. A shake is a blended drink, usually made with a frozen dessert and milk. “Milkshake” is a broad everyday term for that type of drink. A custard shake is therefore a kind of milkshake, but its custard base gives it a different texture and flavor from a typical ice-cream shake.

Menu language can vary, so don’t assume that a store will list every item under the word “milkshake.” Look for shakes on the local menu, or ask whether a particular custard flavor can be made as a shake.

How shakes compare with other Andy’s treats

Andy’s offers several ways to enjoy frozen custard. A shake is blended and served as a drink. Other treats may pair custard with toppings, sauces, or mix-ins without blending everything into a smooth beverage. The right choice depends on whether you want something you can sip, eat with a spoon, or share.

Option	What to expect	Best for
Custard shake	Custard blended into a thick, drinkable dessert	A rich treat you can sip
Concrete	A dense custard treat with mix-ins; generally eaten with a spoon	Getting distinct pieces or flavors in each bite
Sundae	Custard served with toppings or sauce	Enjoying toppings without blending them in
Float	A frozen dessert served with a beverage, depending on the menu	A combination of custard and a drink
Plain frozen custard	Custard served on its own	Tasting the custard without a blended format

Names, recipes, and availability can vary by shop, so treat the table as a general guide rather than a promise that every location carries every item. A shake is the straightforward pick if you want a blended drink. If you prefer to taste separate toppings or mix-ins, ask about a concrete or sundae instead.

One common mix-up is assuming that any custard treat with a topping is a shake. A topping can be placed on a sundae or mixed into another dessert without changing it into a drink. If you specifically want something blended, confirm that you are ordering a shake.

How to choose a shake flavor

Start with the flavor you most enjoy in a frozen dessert. A simple flavor can help you focus on the custard’s rich taste, while a more elaborate combination may suit you if you want added sweetness or variety. Since flavor availability can change by store or season, check the current local menu instead of assuming a particular option is always offered.

1. Choose a familiar base. If you already know which custard flavor you like, ask whether it can be made as a shake. This is an easy way to avoid ordering an unfamiliar combination.
2. Think about sweetness. A shake can feel especially rich when the flavor and additions are sweet. If you want a less intense dessert, ask about a simpler flavor or whether the shop can suggest a lighter-tasting choice.
3. Ask how mix-ins are handled. Some additions may be blended into the shake, while others may be offered as toppings or in a different format. Check before ordering if you want pieces to remain distinct.
4. Consider the size you can finish. A thick shake can be more filling than expected. If you are sharing a meal or ordering other treats, choose a portion that makes sense for your appetite.
5. Confirm current availability. A flavor shown at one location may not be available at another. Ask the staff or review your local shop’s current menu.

If you are ordering for a group, it can help to separate flavor preferences from texture preferences. One person may want a blended drink, while another may prefer a sundae or a spoonable custard treat. Choosing different formats can make it easier for everyone to get what they want.

Are Andy’s shakes suitable for dietary restrictions?

Do not assume a custard shake is dairy-free or egg-free. Frozen custard typically contains dairy and egg, and a shake is made from that custard base. If you have an allergy, intolerance, or other dietary restriction, ask the specific location about ingredients and preparation before ordering.

Ask clearly about the ingredient you need to avoid, not only whether the item is “safe.” For example, if you must avoid milk, ask whether the shake contains milk, cream, or other dairy ingredients. If you must avoid egg, ask whether the custard contains egg. A staff member may need to consult the shop’s current ingredient information.

Also ask about possible cross-contact. This means an allergen can get onto food through shared equipment or preparation surfaces, even when it is not an intended ingredient. The shop can explain its procedures, but you should decide whether those procedures meet your needs.

Ingredient and allergen information can change. If the allergy is severe, do not rely on a general description or an old menu image. Contact the location directly, explain the concern, and ask for current information before placing your order.

What to ask before you order

A short question can prevent a disappointing order, especially if you are looking for a specific flavor or texture. Here are useful prompts:

• “Do you have shakes available right now?”
• “Can this custard flavor be made as a shake?”
• “Is this shake very thick, or can it be made thinner?”
• “Are the mix-ins blended in or served on top?”
• “Can you tell me the current ingredients for this item?”
• “What should I know about allergens or shared equipment?”

These questions are more reliable than assuming every store has the same menu or preparation options. If you are ordering through a delivery app, check the specific location’s listing and read the item details. App menus may not show every customization, so contact the shop if a detail is important.

Common ordering mistakes to avoid

Expecting a thin, easy-to-drink shake

A custard shake can be dense. If you want something lighter or easier to sip, ask about the texture before ordering. Don’t assume that adding a straw means the drink will be thin.

Assuming every location has the same flavors

Stores may differ in available flavors, limited-time choices, and preparation details. Confirm with the location you plan to visit. This is especially helpful if you are traveling or ordering a flavor you have seen elsewhere.

Confusing a concrete with a shake

Both treats can include custard and mix-ins, but a concrete is generally a spoonable dessert rather than a blended drink. State that you want a shake if a drinkable, blended texture is your priority.

Ordering before checking allergy details

A dessert’s name does not tell you its full ingredient list or the risk of cross-contact. Ask the shop for current information and explain the specific ingredient you need to avoid. For a serious allergy, don’t treat a guess as confirmation.

Waiting too long to enjoy it

A blended frozen dessert softens as it warms. If you want the thickest texture, enjoy it soon after pickup. For takeout, keep travel time in mind and avoid leaving it somewhere warm while you run other errands.

Is a shake the right Andy’s order for you?

Choose a shake if you want frozen custard blended into a thick drink. It is a practical choice when you want a treat you can sip, though its richness may make it feel substantial. If you would rather taste separate toppings or keep a firmer, spoonable texture, compare it with a concrete or sundae on the local menu.

For a first order, keep the choice simple: pick a familiar flavor, confirm it is available as a shake, and ask about thickness if you have a strong preference. You can try a more complex flavor combination on another visit once you know how the custard base tastes in a blended drink.

The most useful detail to remember is that “milkshake” can describe the general style, while Andy’s shake is made with its frozen custard. That difference explains why it may taste richer and feel thicker than a standard shake. Check the local menu for current choices, and ask the staff about ingredients or customization before ordering.

Yes, does andy’s frozen custard have milkshakes has a simple answer: Andy’s serves custard-based shakes. Expect a rich, thick drink, and remember that flavors and options may differ by location.

Before you order, check the menu for your local shop and ask about the flavor, texture, or ingredients that matter to you. If you have an allergy, get current ingredient and preparation information directly from the location.